03:48POPlt 11692 words
APTA tells FTA to withdraw CIG guidance rewrite
APTA's formal comments warn that retroactive CIG rules could disqualify nine fully funded projects and low-rate every rail project in the 47-project pipeline, urging FTA to withdraw.
· 3 min journey

Calling at
- Nine projects in eight states hold 100% CIG allocations and await construction agreements
- FTA proposes applying new rules to all 47 projects in the CIG pipeline
- FTA holds $1.9 billion in unallocated CIG funds
- APTA analysis projects all New Starts rail projects would receive low cost-effectiveness ratings
- 70 CIG projects have been built across 22 states over the past decade
Nine transit projects in eight states hold full Capital Investment Grants allocations and wait only for the Federal Transit Administration to sign construction agreements — yet new FTA policy guidance, applied retroactively to all 47 projects in the pipeline, could strip them of that eligibility. The American Public Transportation Association wants the proposal withdrawn.
In formal comments filed with FTA, APTA argues the draft guidance for the CIG program contradicts statute, exceeds the agency's authority and would impose new costs, delays and uncertainty on communities building bus rapid transit, light rail and subway extensions. The program has produced 70 projects across 22 states over the past decade.
"Communities have spent years and millions of local dollars meeting FTA's rules under the CIG program," APTA President and CEO Paul Skoutelas said. "This new proposal moves the goalposts on them. Nine projects are already at the goal line, fully funded and waiting only for FTA to sign a construction agreement."
What does APTA say the proposal changes?
The association lays out six objections. The first is legal: since 2020, Congress has barred FTA from impeding projects seeking more than 40% of their costs from CIG. The proposal introduces a multi-part rubric, absent from statute, that would require some projects to exceed the medium rating the law demands to qualify for a higher federal share.
The draft would also raise cost effectiveness to 25% of a project's justification rating — five times the weight of the lowest criterion — though the law requires "comparable" weight across all six criteria. APTA further questions the inclusion of marriage and birth rates as factors awarding a higher federal share, calling them unrelated to the program's purpose.
The remaining objections are operational:
- Cost and delay. Sponsors that spent years advancing through the multi-step process would face re-evaluations and potential redesigns.
- Bureaucratic barriers. New Starts and Core Capacity sponsors would identify more local funds earlier while shouldering full financial risk until a construction agreement is signed. APTA says FTA sets new cost-effectiveness thresholds without justification, ignores inflation and applies identical thresholds to all project types despite rail costing more than most BRT corridors.
- A $600 million cost cap that excludes most large projects from expedited review.
- Uncertainty. The proposal expands FTA authority without explaining its administration, creating what APTA calls a more arbitrary and opaque review process.
What is at stake for rail?
A preliminary APTA analysis finds all New Starts transit rail projects in the pipeline would receive a low cost-effectiveness rating under the proposal. Because that criterion carries the most weight in the proposed federal-share formula, rail projects would draw less federal investment, and none could qualify for expedited review.
The timing compounds the concern. FTA holds $1.9 billion in unallocated CIG funds, which APTA says makes the rationale for reducing the federal share unclear.
How large is the economic footprint?
Almost 3,000 suppliers in more than 1,700 communities across all 50 states manufacture the buses, railcars and infrastructure used in CIG projects. APTA cites industry figures that every $1 invested in public transit generates $5 in long-term economic return, and that 77% of federal transit investment flows to private-sector American companies and workers. These are association projections, not audited results.
APTA asks FTA to take three steps: withdraw the guidance; publish the impacts of the proposed changes on each of the 47 pipeline projects, including a list of those that no longer qualify for a construction grant agreement; and work with industry on streamlining, starting with moving the nine fully funded projects to construction.
A further complication: FTA adopted its current guidance only a year ago, and Congress is drafting the next surface transportation authorization, which will likely reshape CIG and require new guidance regardless.
"Congress is writing the next surface transportation bill right now, and that is the right place to shape the future of this program," Skoutelas said. "Let's get these projects built, not send them back to the starting line."
FTA has not publicly responded to the comments, and no deadline for a decision on the proposed guidance has been announced.
via apta.com (Original)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
News editor covering technology and product news in Rail industry news and analysis at Mainline Report.
407 articles
Connecting services · Related articles
- 24:44
APTA Calls on Congress to Hold Transit, Rail Funding Steady for FY 2027
- 22:33
FTA Puts $166M Into US Passenger Rail Modernization
- 24:54
US federal passenger rail and transit funding cuts take effect
- 02:50
House Stopgap Bill Would Cut US Passenger Rail Funding by 83%
- 01:13
California high-speed rail funding could run dry by December 2027